It seems like Robinson thinks the root problem with the modern education system is two fold. First, he argues modern education hinges upon 19th century ideas of intellect. Teachers emphasize the classics and other unnecessary topics with no real world application, and the effect is this marginalizes students who are intelligent but also disinterested in these subjects. Secondly, Robinson argues that this structure comes from outdated modes of thinking economically. He says that modern educators believe these subjects are beneficial because they will create jobs for the students, who need to know about these pivotal topics. However, the problem is that, not only do students doubt their ability to get a job with a bachelor's degree, but they are also right to do so. Unfortunately, we are teaching students to doubt their abilities and value outdated definitions of intelligence, which leads to even more economic hardship and perpetuates this ridiculous system.
I think he is right to a point. Many educators indeed abide by this system and refuse to adapt to the changing climate of economic and intellectual need (see instructors who refuse to acknowledge the importance of technology). However, I also think that his idea falls short of revolutionary in that many people already thought the same thing, even though few could articulate it with such clarity, intelligence and interesting artwork. Many educators are adapting already, so he is only educating the few who cleave to antiquated ideas. Unfortunately, I sometimes cleave to these antiquated ideas, having been brought up in this education system, seen few who challenge it (well) and lack the experience to question my own practices (as Esquith did). What a tricky subject, teaching. I know doctors now take classes to learn how to talk with patients, and I wish I took more classes on methodology rather than how to use power point.
In his last several minutes he discusses divergent thinking and subtly compels teachers to rethink human capacity to encourage creativity. As a language teacher I think I can do this by making lessons that interest the students. This means I must discuss their favorite subjects, not mine. If they are interested in cars, hairstyling or organic chemistry, I must figure out ways to let them discuss/investigate these topics. Perhaps as part of the curriculum I can assign speeches that they must present, which will target speaking, listening, writing and perhaps reading if they make note cards or attempt to memorize the entire speech. I can assign reading work out of their favorite magazines or books of popular interest...not sure how I will get some of these given their economic level, but I guess that is another hurdle to discuss divergently. I will have to show them how language helps them do what they want, like understand the intended words of a film or book rather than relying on one person's interpretation (as fun as those can be). As I do this more and more I feel like I have bitten off more than I can chew becoming a teacher. It seems like a 24 hour job and I don't know enough yet to be the teacher I want to be. Damn this human experience of growth and learning!
No comments:
Post a Comment